Knife or Bat?

[AceLosesKing]

Interesting thread I came across on 2+2 the other day.

There are two fighters, matched equally in size, speed, strength. There are no advantages to either man. A fight to the death is organised.

Knife or (baseball) bat?

[bennymacca]

knife

although a bat has a longer reach, you only really need to connect once with a knife.

[AceLosesKing]

knife

although a bat has a longer reach, you only really need to connect once with a knife.

It would depend where, if I can hit you twice with the bat in the head I'd say that's game over.

[madali]

I say bat as you can knock the knife out of his hand and then bam.

[bennymacca]

what, no poll?

stupid thread without a poll!

[Sinitster]

hrmnnnnnnnn .... Knife , Bat , or poll ? ? ?

Still bat for me

[bennymacca]

hrmnnnnnnnn .... Knife , Bat , or poll ? ? ?

Still bat for me

lol you idiot

[maccatak11]

bat. much better as a defensive weapon compared to a knife i.e. you can block a knife attack easier too. Much easier to disarm your opponent with a bat than a knife.

[bennymacca]

yeah, but lets say you lunged for the guy and he wacked you with a bat. if you get your arm up to defend, it might break your arm, but if you stab the guy at the same time, he will be much worse off.

so i reckon kamikaze with the knife and finish the fight before it starts

[maccatak11]

but ill smash your face in with the bat before you even get close with the knife.